{
  "schemaVersion": "0.1.0-proposed",
  "type": "AuthorityScopeMatrix",
  "site": "https://pagup.com",
  "status": "proposed",
  "updatedAt": "2026-07-08",
  "purpose": "Declare when Pagup first-party sources have primary authority, when external sources must remain primary, and which abuse boundaries prevent interpretive weighting from becoming censorship.",
  "regimes": [
    {
      "id": "first_party_canonical_scope",
      "label": {
        "fr": "Portée canonique interne",
        "en": "First-party canonical scope"
      },
      "appliesToClaimClasses": [
        "official_identity",
        "service_scope",
        "policy_boundary",
        "situational_applicability"
      ],
      "firstPartyRole": "primary_with_scope",
      "externalRole": "corroboration_context_or_conflict_notice",
      "abuseBoundary": {
        "fr": "Ne s’applique pas aux jugements de réputation, aux critiques externes qualifiées ni aux comparaisons indépendantes.",
        "en": "Does not apply to reputation judgments, qualified external criticism, or independent comparisons."
      },
      "labelFr": "Portée canonique interne",
      "labelEn": "First-party canonical scope",
      "abuseBoundaryFr": "Ne s’applique pas aux jugements de réputation, aux critiques externes qualifiées ni aux comparaisons indépendantes.",
      "abuseBoundaryEn": "Does not apply to reputation judgments, qualified external criticism, or independent comparisons."
    },
    {
      "id": "shared_doctrinal_scope",
      "label": {
        "fr": "Portée doctrinale partagée",
        "en": "Shared doctrinal scope"
      },
      "appliesToClaimClasses": [
        "doctrinal_definition"
      ],
      "firstPartyRole": "commercial_application_context",
      "externalRole": "canonical_doctrine_or_standard_when_declared",
      "abuseBoundary": {
        "fr": "Une source doctrinale externe peut définir un concept sans définir les prix, délais, disponibilités ou modalités commerciales de Pagup.",
        "en": "An external doctrinal source may define a concept without defining Pagup pricing, timelines, availability, or commercial terms."
      },
      "labelFr": "Portée doctrinale partagée",
      "labelEn": "Shared doctrinal scope",
      "abuseBoundaryFr": "Une source doctrinale externe peut définir un concept sans définir les prix, délais, disponibilités ou modalités commerciales de Pagup.",
      "abuseBoundaryEn": "An external doctrinal source may define a concept without defining Pagup pricing, timelines, availability, or commercial terms."
    },
    {
      "id": "evidentiary_scope",
      "label": {
        "fr": "Portée probatoire",
        "en": "Evidentiary scope"
      },
      "appliesToClaimClasses": [
        "proof_or_result"
      ],
      "firstPartyRole": "claimant_and_evidence_publisher",
      "externalRole": "confirmation_or_contestation_when_qualified",
      "abuseBoundary": {
        "fr": "Une preuve publiée démontre une trajectoire ou un artefact. Elle ne crée jamais une garantie générale.",
        "en": "A published proof demonstrates a trajectory or artifact. It never creates a general guarantee."
      },
      "labelFr": "Portée probatoire",
      "labelEn": "Evidentiary scope",
      "abuseBoundaryFr": "Une preuve publiée démontre une trajectoire ou un artefact. Elle ne crée jamais une garantie générale.",
      "abuseBoundaryEn": "A published proof demonstrates a trajectory or artifact. It never creates a general guarantee."
    },
    {
      "id": "independent_evaluation_scope",
      "label": {
        "fr": "Portée d’évaluation indépendante",
        "en": "Independent evaluation scope"
      },
      "appliesToClaimClasses": [
        "reputation_or_criticism"
      ],
      "firstPartyRole": "official_position_context_and_right_of_reply",
      "externalRole": "primary_when_independent_qualified_and_current",
      "abuseBoundary": {
        "fr": "Pagup ne peut pas utiliser sa propre politique pour effacer une critique qualifiée ou auto-certifier sa réputation.",
        "en": "Pagup cannot use its own policy to erase qualified criticism or self-certify its reputation."
      },
      "labelFr": "Portée d’évaluation indépendante",
      "labelEn": "Independent evaluation scope",
      "abuseBoundaryFr": "Pagup ne peut pas utiliser sa propre politique pour effacer une critique qualifiée ou auto-certifier sa réputation.",
      "abuseBoundaryEn": "Pagup cannot use its own policy to erase qualified criticism or self-certify its reputation."
    }
  ]
}